Here is a quick look back at Butch's first 3 recruiting classes (still early to judge the last 2). Butch definitely got some studs, but his classes have been overrated and very injury-prone (as @acolli05 pointed out in a post yesterday). Thoughts? Has Butch just done a poor job of developing talent and keeping guys in the program? Did he just sign highly-rated guys without proper evaluation and consideration of injury history? Does this talent equate to that of a top-10 or top-25 program?
2013 - 21st nationally
Kendal Vickers - solid starter
Joshua Dobbs - NFL
Malik Brown
Jaylen Miller
Jabo Lee - didn't make it to TN
Woody Quinn - BUST
Ryan Jenkins - left TN
Dylan Wiesman - decent player
A.J. Branisel - left TN
Malik Foreman - decent player
Riyahd Jones - BUST
Lemond Johnson - BUST
Jalen Reeves-Maybin - NFL
Cameron Sutton - NFL
Paul Harris - left TN
Riley Ferguson - left TN / will make NFL
Josh Smith - decent player
Brett Kendrick - decent player
Corey Vereen - solid player
Jason Carr - bust / left program
Austin Sanders
Marquez North - solid player
2014 - 5th nationally
Michael Sawyers - left TN
Derrell Scott - left TN
Jashon Robertson - solid player
Charles Mosley - BUST
Josh Malone - NFL
Jakob Johnson - decent player
Owen Williams - decent player
Evan Berry - great returner
Dewayne Hendrix - left TN
Lavon Pearson - left TN
Derek Barnett - NFL
Dontavius Blair - BUST
Emmanuel Moseley - decent player
Rashaan Gaulden - solid player
Ray Raulerson
Cortez McDowell - decent player
Dillon Bates - BUST
Gavin Bryant
Chris Weatherd
Joe Henderson - left TN
Aaron Medley - decent player
Daniel Helm - left TN
Ethan Wolf - solid player
D'Andre Payne - left TN?
Treyvon Paulk - left TN
Jalen Hurd - left TN / great player
Neiko Creamer - BUST
Todd Kelly - great player
Coleman Thomas - decent player
Vic Wharton - left TN
Elliot Berry
2015 - 5th nationally
Drew Richmond - BUST
Quarte Sapp - decent player
John Kelly - great player / maybe NFL
Justin Martin - decent player
Sheriron Jones - left TN
Kyle Phillips - decent player
Darrin Kirkland Jr. - good player
Micah Abernathy - solid player
Shy Tuttle - good player
Darrell Taylor - good player
Venzell Boulware - left TN
Darrell Miller
Kahlil McKenzie - decent player
Chance Hall - decent player
Tommy Townsend
Kyle Oliver - didn't make it to TN
Quay Pico
Austin Smith
Alvin Kamara - NFL
Quinten Dormady
Jauan Jennings - good player
Stephen Griffin
Riley Lovingood
Preston Williams - left TN
Andrew Butcher
Jack Jones - good player
Zach Stewart - didn't make it to TN
Vincent Perry - left TN
Jocquez Bruce - didn't make it to TN
2013 - 21st nationally
Kendal Vickers - solid starter
Joshua Dobbs - NFL
Malik Brown
Jaylen Miller
Jabo Lee - didn't make it to TN
Woody Quinn - BUST
Ryan Jenkins - left TN
Dylan Wiesman - decent player
A.J. Branisel - left TN
Malik Foreman - decent player
Riyahd Jones - BUST
Lemond Johnson - BUST
Jalen Reeves-Maybin - NFL
Cameron Sutton - NFL
Paul Harris - left TN
Riley Ferguson - left TN / will make NFL
Josh Smith - decent player
Brett Kendrick - decent player
Corey Vereen - solid player
Jason Carr - bust / left program
Austin Sanders
Marquez North - solid player
2014 - 5th nationally
Michael Sawyers - left TN
Derrell Scott - left TN
Jashon Robertson - solid player
Charles Mosley - BUST
Josh Malone - NFL
Jakob Johnson - decent player
Owen Williams - decent player
Evan Berry - great returner
Dewayne Hendrix - left TN
Lavon Pearson - left TN
Derek Barnett - NFL
Dontavius Blair - BUST
Emmanuel Moseley - decent player
Rashaan Gaulden - solid player
Ray Raulerson
Cortez McDowell - decent player
Dillon Bates - BUST
Gavin Bryant
Chris Weatherd
Joe Henderson - left TN
Aaron Medley - decent player
Daniel Helm - left TN
Ethan Wolf - solid player
D'Andre Payne - left TN?
Treyvon Paulk - left TN
Jalen Hurd - left TN / great player
Neiko Creamer - BUST
Todd Kelly - great player
Coleman Thomas - decent player
Vic Wharton - left TN
Elliot Berry
2015 - 5th nationally
Drew Richmond - BUST
Quarte Sapp - decent player
John Kelly - great player / maybe NFL
Justin Martin - decent player
Sheriron Jones - left TN
Kyle Phillips - decent player
Darrin Kirkland Jr. - good player
Micah Abernathy - solid player
Shy Tuttle - good player
Darrell Taylor - good player
Venzell Boulware - left TN
Darrell Miller
Kahlil McKenzie - decent player
Chance Hall - decent player
Tommy Townsend
Kyle Oliver - didn't make it to TN
Quay Pico
Austin Smith
Alvin Kamara - NFL
Quinten Dormady
Jauan Jennings - good player
Stephen Griffin
Riley Lovingood
Preston Williams - left TN
Andrew Butcher
Jack Jones - good player
Zach Stewart - didn't make it to TN
Vincent Perry - left TN
Jocquez Bruce - didn't make it to TN
Last edited: